Well here we are...hours away from finding out who will be the Top 12 Finalists for AI's Season 7. Unfortunately, the rules say that the top 12 must be six guys and six girls. This season, it would be a much better show with 7 guys and 5 girls. But rules are rules... So here is how the top 8 girls fared in their last attempt before the finals:
Asia'h Epperson - I actually loved her performance of Whitney's "Dance with Somebody". She's got such a big smile, and she genuinely had fun with the song. I agree with the Entertainment Weekly suggestion that all of Whitney Houston's songs be banned from American Idol. I really like Asia'h's personality and hope she stays in the competition.
Kady Malloy - She absolutely brutalized one of my favorite Queen songs. She was very off on the big notes, and she kinda comes off as a bitch. She absolutely needs to go!
Carly Smithson - I didn't recognize the song she sang, but it was very good. She has an ugly face when she screams out the big notes, but she still hits them. One of the few girls that actually deserves to be in the finals.
Brooke White - I have never been a fan of the Pat Benatar song she sang, but she put a really nice spin on it that made it much more appealing to me. As usual, Randy and Paula have awful opinions. I think Simon has a little crush on Brooke. He gives her a lot more praise that I think she deserves. But again, she is definitely Finals material.
Amanda Overmyer - I am definitely NOT drinking the Kool-Aid on her. She is not a good vocalist, and an even worse performer. She stares at the ground the entire time when she sings. She doesn't smile, doesn't laugh, and is overall just boring. She'll probably make it through, but I hope she doesn't stay for too long.
Kristy Lee Cook - Man, I want her to be good. She's got a great look, and even has a decent voice. But she definitely lost some serious points with her "I acted like a dog" story. That isn't embarassing, it's grounds for being institutionalized. She's definitely on the fence. I won't be surprised either way if she stays or goes.
Ramiele Malubay - I can't stand her. She has a very strong voice, but she is so boring when she performs. She stands in one place. She doesn't try to "work the crowd" or anything. I hope she goes, but again, I won't be surprised.
Syesha Mercado - Again, I didn't recognize the song. She sang it very well. She has a strong voice. However, she's so far a one-trick pony. I don't see much room for variety in her.
Needless to say, I was very unimpressed with the girls tonight. My guess (or hope) is that Kady Malloy and Syesha Mercado go home tonight. Ah hell, who knows.
Thursday, March 6, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment