Tuesday, March 25, 2008

AI: The Top Ten

So I'll keep this short and sweet. Gotta get to bed.

Ramiele - Considering we've already seen Carly sing that song during Hollywood week, it probably wasn't a wise choice. For my money, nobody did it better than Carrie Underwood, and Ramiele is no Carrie Underwood. I'm really hoping she gets bit by the "Going First Curse".

Jason Castro - Who's voting for this guy? He's not a talented singer, plain and simple. Simon had it right that he's like a busker outside a subway. He's a good strummer, sure, but is he ever going to really sing?

Syesha - One of my favorite performances of the night. Even though I didn't know her song, she clearly sang it well. She's got a lot of soul in that voice. And she ain't bad to look at either. One thing I'm tired of is she keeps saying "Oh Lo" during her judging. I think I've heard it from Ramiele also. It's probably some stupid inside joke about how one of their mothers says "Oh Lord". Please stop.

Chikezie - Kind of a downer since his last two weeks, but overall it was good. Again, Simon has it right, he is very old-fashioned. He's definitely heading to the Luther Vandross demographic. But I like his voice and his performances. Stick around please.

Brooke White - Eesh. Not a good arrangement of the song. Has shown a lot of vulnerability lately. I'm glad she's back behind the piano. She has NO RYTHYM. (See last week) Just stay on a piano bench or stool and don't move.

Michael Johns - Finally, I loved his performance. He was starting to lose it, but this week's Queen performance blew me away. Match it up with is Bohemian Rhapsody from Hollywood week, and maybe we've found his only nitch is Queen music. Unfortunately, he probably won't be able to get away with that the whole competition. But at least this was a memorable performance. The only issue now is, has he peaked too soon?

Carly Smithson - Not as bad as the judges made it seem. She can shreik like there's no tomorrow. Still, I can't help but feel like the judges simply don't want her to win.

David Archuleta - What the hell song was that? Is that going to be his number one single from his debut album "The Little Davey Happy Time Love One-another Extravaganza" ? Don't get me wrong, he sang it beautifully, but Simon said it, there needed to be costumed characters jumping around and hugging everybody. I still like him a lot, but he needs to pick better songs.

Kristly Lee Cook - Was Simon patronizing her that she picked a song that people would love regardless of how she sang it? I mean, she sang it very well, and mostly on-key. But with Amazing Grace and God Bless The U.S.A. under her belt, can God Bless America be that far behind? I don't know what else to say about her. I can all but guarantee she'll be in the bottom 2, but will she survive yet again?

David Cook - Okay, can someone who sings another person's cover of another person's song be called creative and original? What if they did it three weeks in a row? I'm not sure how I feel about this. All of the singers want to make each song "their own", but is it okay if they copy someone else's "their own"? At least he's giving credit where it's due. He's trying not to take full credit for the arrangements. Regardless, he's a great singer and will surely front a band soon enough.

No comments: